Computer Reviews and Computer Products ? Computer Shopper

CNET Archive BETA

Find more recent VOIP / Internet Phone products


advertisement

NETGEAR Skype Wi-Fi Phone (discontinued)

NETGEAR Skype Wi-Fi Phone

Entered CNET Catalog: 12/21/2005

SKU: SPH101

Manufacturer: NetGear Inc.

Manufacturer description

NETGEAR's Skype WiFi Phone is the world's first wireless Internet phone that can make free calls to other Skype users anywhere in the world, anytime you have WiFi access, without a PC. All of your contacts are shown right on the phone's color display so you will know exactly who is on-line. You will also be more available for your friends to call, because you no longer have to be on your PC to be connected. You can even make calls to ordinary phones using Skype-Out for just pennies a minute and no monthly fees. With the Skype WiFi Phone, NETGEAR makes true mobile wireless Internet telephony a reality.

User opinions

Select a User Opinion to view: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17

User Rating: 1/10

Poor call quality, sluggish response,poor battery life.

Pros: Small size.

Cons: Poor call quality, sluggish response, poor standby battery life.

Review: skype to land line calls: I can hear the caller pretty well but they have a difficult time hearing me. I know it's not my internet connection because if I make the same call with a hardwired skype headset, the call is crystal clear. The phone also gets pretty warm and the battery life is poor. There is also an annoying delay when pressing any of the buttons. It's as if the firmware is sluggish. It has also locked up on me several times. I would not recommend this product.

User Rating: 3/10

Poor Call Quality but easy to setup and Use

Pros: Size, Software, Ease of Setup

Cons: Call Quality-people I called said the phone quality was terrible though it was good on my side.

Review: Buy something else! I would recommend buying a Skype Phone with DECT support unless you are going to carry the phone around to different hotspots. If you need to roam to hotspots, try another brand.

User Rating: 1/10

terrible phone

Pros: looks nice

Cons: doesn't work

Review: phone heats up so hot it will burn your ear. battery has very short lifetime. phone continually drops signal. Don't buy this phone - it's not ready for primetime!

User Rating: 7/10

Best 1st wifi phone generation

Pros: Easy to use and lightweight

Cons: handsfree jack doesn't work and only 2-3hrs of continue talk time/ 24hrs standby time. Then number pad is hard and u have to user your fingertips one at a time with a little delay.

Review: This is a great phone to have at home or open wifi keeping your computer off during the night. Unforutantly this doesn't have any kind of web broswer for web login. I really enjoy my netgear skype wifi phone. I was sad to find out that handsfree jack not working. I called about it and they told me that it was a common problem. If I would have know I problobly would have bought a dual skype and lan cordless instead. I think that this is the best in its class. I can't wait to see new ones. NETGEAR FIX you headphone jack.

User Rating: 6/10

Usable but there are quirks and no hope for upgrade

Pros: Skype can be used without PC

Cons: Quirks which reduce its usability

Review: This phone works with Skype. But... there are some quirks:

- it seems does not work as well as PC at least I have this impression. It has tendency to cut phonems. Anyway, remember to have good WiFi link.

- it seems the phone is not completely stable or recovers when there is problem with the network, it has to be reset from time to time

- annoying quirk is that call ID does not work like in cordless phones. Thats is if you have a name stored in memory and a call comes from this name, only the number is displayed and no name.

- using DTMF tones is awkward, they have to be called from a list, not directly from keypad, they can not be stored.

- there is no hope for software upgrade. This phone is not made by Netgear and apparently they outsourced support too.

- power supply goes through USB-shaped connector. I wonder why the phone could not have craddle like in the wired network model

In the end, the phone works, and can be used. If networks are fine, it works fine. But the quirks make it less than ideal and it could be ideal if software upgrade would be provided.

User Rating: 1/10

Is this some type of joke?

Pros: None whatseover

Cons: Everything about it

Review: This phone was a complete waste of time. Half of the time it doesn't see my wi-fi network. When it does the phone is overheating and losing its charge in a matter of minutes. This phone is garbage. I know that the phone isn't just having battery issues because I found others who had the same exact problems with this phone.

User Rating: 7/10

Does what it claims on the box

Pros: Easy to use, but read the manual

Cons: No chat, & battery life only a few hours

Review: Having read some of the negative reviews, I must have bought a different product. The sound quality is excellent, it's easy to use, the auto connect & log-on works fine provided you have set the phone to do this - read the manual! Perhaps the reported problems are down to early firmware - download the upgrade, which is quite straightforward. Chat, ie SMS, is not supported, which is a pity. The only other downside is the battery life - Netgear claim 20 hours - mine's around 7 to 8 hours.

User Rating: 1/10

This phone is bad, but the Netgear customer service is the worst ever!!!

Pros: unfortunately none

Cons: the phone does not perform

Review: I received my Netgear phone and it had many issues. It could be I just received a bad unit. But trying to send it back and get a replacement was the worst experience I have ever had. Customer Service is brutal. I will never buy a Netgear product again!!!!!!!!!

User Rating: 7/10

Room for refinement, but a solid start

Pros: High quality construction, Trivial to set up and use

Cons: Outgoing audio is a little muffled, gets hot, uses up battery

Review: First impression was of the physical quality of the handset. It's compact and very solid with sturdy feeling buttons. It feels better built than most cell phones I've touched. I guess I expected something flimsy like a Logitech grade webcam or the Netgear routers or something.

I turned it on and was going to grab the manual to get it configured. I saw my network listed, I selected and entered my WPA password, then entered my Skype credentials. I was about to then get the manual to see what else I had to do when I realized I was already connected, up and running. Setup is a snap, though only with simple home networks. It doesn't support any custom web based logins.

Button layout is intuitive. It was easy to make calls. Other party sounds solid, but they noticed a lack of resolution in my speech. I cross checked and confirmed that the outgoing audio is a little muffled. Under worse conditions, the lack of crispness would reduce intelligibility, but I wasn't being asked to repeat myself.

After a five minute phone call, I was well aware of the LCD display which was warming my cheek like a warm washcloth.

If you want to be ready to take calls, remember to leave it charged. Otherwise the battery dies without warning in a day or so.

I'd say this phone is ready for the real world. It is clearly a 1st generation device with room for maturing and refinement, but as a first pass, it's a solid start and ready to use.

User Rating: 1/10

This product does not work. Poor performance

Pros: Look like an interesting Toy for Holidays

Cons: Bad design. Poor user interface

Review: This product is a total junk. Does not work with own Netgear WGR router. The wireless connection drops and reconnects in random. The call quality is ok, but the battery stand by and up time with calls is less than 1 hour and unit dies.
Netgear claims that this phone is a very easy to setup... They must be referring to some other Skype phone...Do not waist your money on this garbage.

User Rating: 3/10

Basic features lacking, battery life <1 day standby!!

Pros: works if you leave plugged into the wall & don't move

Cons: not useful as a home cordless phone over VOIP

Review: Was excited to get this phone then very disappointed quickly. The login is not persistent, when attaching/detaching power it logs you off Skype. Stored auto-login failed to persist, have to type in login everytime. Not useful for people to call you unless you leave it plugged into the wall. Skype-out calls start ringing as late as after the 2nd ring. My broadband service is fiber 5down/2up so call quality was decent.

User Rating: 1/10

Great idea, lousy execution

Pros: looks good

Cons: never was able to connect to my network. Returned it

Review: I was excited about getting this phone being an avid skype user. However after spending 1 hour on the phone with a Netgear technican in India who had no idea on how to get it to work, I returned it to buy.com. Netgear service sucks and this phone could never connect to my belkin pre n router even after disabling the security on my router. The phone would not connect to my network.

User Rating: 2/10

Boo this Device

Pros: Easy to use, quick connection to network

Cons: Packet Loss, Burns its battery out quickly,

Review: At first I loved the phone but the amount of packet loss this thing expierances is unbelieveable,trying to have a conversation without repeating yourself several times is next to impossible. When you make Skypeout calls the person on the receiving end often hangs up because they can't hear you for the first 2.5 - 5 seconds. Oh did I forget to mention that when the mic portion of the phone touches your face or gets covered you and the person your talking to expierance deafening feed back I bought 2 and they are both on the way back to the supplier for my money back

User Rating: 7/10

Looks good, but WAIT for Web-based log-in, integration with phone services, etc.

Pros: Uses Skype via Wi-Fi Support, Comes from Netgear, a trusted company

Cons: No Web-Based Log In, Not yet integrated with your home phone service or cellular service...

Review: While the Netgear Skype WiFi phone seems like the perfect phone to use Skype on, this technology is still relatively new, and I personally think you should wait until better technology is available instead of dropping $180 for this phone, or even more. They're two problems with this phone already:

1) No Web-Based Log In: This means that even if you have T-Mobile or Verizon's powerful Wi-Fi access plans, you will not be able to access wi-fi. Why is this a problem? Most access hotspots require web-based log in.

2) Not Integrated with your Home Phone/Cellular Device: This means that you need two devices at home: a set of home phones & a Skype phone. Why is this a problem? If you're like me, you enjoy the all-in-one hybrid devices.

User Rating: 6/10

does not support web based log-in , urghhhh

Pros: no PC required

Cons: does not support hotspots

Review: this phone will not allow you to log on to subscription based public hotspots (such as T-Mobile) as it does not have a browser... My reason for not buying one, because my Linksys skype phone connected to my PC is fine for home use and half the price. I like the Netgear phone, but I cannot see sales surge until the price drops and public hotspot support will be integrated...

User Rating: 8/10

the future...i hope

Pros: Not Available

Cons: Not Available

Review: i've never owned a mobile phone because i don't want to pay for it. i don't even think about how much it would cost me to call my friends in other countries on a mobile network. i've been waiting for someone to make this product for a year, and it's finally here. i'm sure this first generation product will have flaws, but imagine a phone that's free. and using skype out and skype in, it'll work as a regular mobile....that is when you're near a wifi spot. this phone will already be very handy for cheap people like me, but imagine how great this phone will be when wifi becomes more widespread. i hope they make its software upgradable.

User Rating: 10/10

Nice product !

Pros: Nice product !

Cons: Nice product !

Review: Easy use and easy setup !
get one right a way.

Keywords

wi-fi   |   wireless   |   VoIP phone   |   mobile phone   |   internet phone   |   Wi-Fi phone   |   wifi   |   wi-fi hotspots   |   WEP   |   WPA   |   WPA2   |   skype   |   skype phone   |   SkypeOut   |   Skype Out   |  

About CNET Archive BETA

Welcome to the CNET Archive, a library of product reviews, user opinions, videos, specifications, and manufacturer descriptions for products no longer offered by the manufacturer or most retailers. Here you will find information on replacement parts and replacement ink cartridges. Read what others had to say about that used laptop you are considering buying. Take a trip down memory lane as you browse and reminisce about your favorite old video game or that first digital camera.

NETGEAR Skype Wi-Fi Phone specifications

  • Phone Features
  • VoIP Services Skype
  • Max Handsets Supported 4.0
  • Dialer Type Keypad
  • Dialer Location Handset
  • IP Telephony
  • Security 128 bit WEP , 40 bit WEP , 64 bit WEP
  • Display
  • Display LCD display - Color
  • Display Location Handset
  • Features Backlit
  • Miscellaneous
  • Placing / Mounting Table-top
  • Power
  • Type Power adapter - External
  • Battery
  • Battery 1.0 x battery
  • Technology Rechargeable
  • Audible Battery Alert Yes
  • Dimensions & Weight (Handset)
  • Width 1.9 in
  • Depth 1.4 in
  • Height 5.2 in
  • Weight 0.3 lbs
  • Manufacturer Warranty
  • Service & Support 2 year warranty
advertisement
advertisement