Computer Reviews and Computer Products – Computer Shopper
Computer Shopper > Reviews > Computer Systems


Search:
Go!


advertisement

Which Draft N router is right for you?

Felisa Yang
Felisa Yang, Associate Editor
July 31, 2006
With the release of the first draft of the 802.11n specification by the IEEE came a flurry of product releases from the major networking vendors. Each company put its own spin on the new routers, from hidden antennas to paddle antennas to user-friendly network-display panels. With so many choices, how can you tell which is right for you? That's a tough question to answer. All of these products' throughput numbers looked stellar when compared to the throughput of standard 802.11g routers, but they all fell short of the promised speed improvement of 802.11n (according to the spec, the max throughput is 270Mbps). And there is a slight chance (unlikely, but not impossible) that some major change in the final 802.11n spec could render these product nonupgradable. Our advice dovetails with that of industry analysts: if you already have a wireless home network, keep using it until the spec has been finalized (expected to be around mid-2007) to see how the final performances stack up.

If you absolutely can't wait and need to have one of these routers now, we liked the D-Link N 650 for its fast performance and wealth of features and the Belkin N1 router for its unparalleled user-friendliness.

Also, don't forget to check these routers' companion wireless notebook adapters.


  remove this product remove this product remove this product remove this product remove this product remove this product
Product name Belkin N1 Wireless Router
Belkin N1 Wireless Router  
D-Link RangeBooster N 650 Wireless Router
D-Link RangeBooster N 650 Wireless Router  
Buffalo AirStation Nfiniti router and AP
Buffalo AirStation Nfiniti router and AP  
Linksys WRT300N Router
Linksys WRT300N Router  
Netgear WNR834B RangeMax Next Router
Netgear WNR834B RangeMax Next Router  
Trendnet Wireless N-Draft Router
Trendnet Wireless N-Draft Router  







Review date June 19, 2006   July 20, 2006   July 28, 2006   April 24, 2006   May 03, 2006   October 13, 2006  







CNET editors' rating 7.8 out of 10 7.8
Very good
6.9 out of 10 6.9
Good
6.4 out of 10 6.4
Good
6.7 out of 10 6.7
Good
6.3 out of 10 6.3
Good
7.1 out of 10 7.1
Very good







Users' rating 5.0 out of 10 5.0
Average
5.2 out of 10 5.2
Average
Be one of the first to rate this product! 4.7 out of 10 4.7
Mediocre
4.5 out of 10 4.5
Mediocre
7.5 out of 10 7.5
Very good







Buying choices
Prices from online stores:
processing...

Searching for pricing data...


 
Prices from online stores:
processing...

Searching for pricing data...


 
Prices from online stores:
processing...

Searching for pricing data...


 
Prices from online stores:
processing...

Searching for pricing data...


 
Prices from online stores:
processing...

Searching for pricing data...


 
Prices from online stores:
processing...

Searching for pricing data...


 







Local shopping No local stores found No local stores found No local stores found No local stores found No local stores found No local stores found







Product videos Watch video       Watch video Watch video







Review summary With its easy-to-grasp status icons, up-to-date security options, and stellar support, the Belkin N1 router is on the path to 802.11n wireless networking stardom, but like other Draft N devices, its performance fails to impress. Though inconsistent, the D-Link N 650 router performed admirably overall compared to its Draft N competition. Still, we are unimpressed with how it measures up to the promise of 802.11n. Pass on this for now; in fact, pass on all Draft N routers until the spec is finalized. Although the Buffalo Nfiniti router performed admirably in its somewhat limited mixed-mode operation, like every other Draft N router we've tested, it fails to deliver on the promise of 802.11n. Though it offers good maximum throughput, the Linksys WRT300N ultimately fails to do the new Draft N standard proud in both mixed-mode and long-range tests. Wait to see how the rest of the Draft N products fare. Though its maximum throughput is solid and its speed at long range is respectable, the Netgear WNR834B's mixed-mode speed is not. Save your cash until more Draft N routers make it through CNET Labs. The Trendnet TEW-631BRP's throughput scores led the pack of Draft N routers, but hold your horses and wait to see how the 802.11n spec pans out.







My Products
Basic Specs
Product Description Belkin N1 Wireless Router - Wireless router D-Link RangeBooster N 650 Router DIR-635 - Wireless router Buffalo AirStation Nfiniti WZR-G300N Wireless-N Router & Access Point - Wireless router Linksys Wireless-N Broadband Router WRT300N - Wireless router NETGEAR RangeMax Next Wireless Router WNR834B - Wireless router TRENDnet TEW 631BRP - Wireless router







Device Type Wireless router + 4-port switch (integrated) Wireless router + 4-port switch (integrated) Wireless router + 4-port switch (integrated) Wireless router + 4-port switch (integrated) Wireless router + 4-port switch (integrated) Wireless router + 4-port switch (integrated)







Form Factor External External External External External External







Data Transfer Rate 300 Mbps Info unavailable 108 Mbps Info unavailable 270 Mbps 300 Mbps







Frequency Band 2.4 GHz 2.4 GHz 2.4 GHz 2.4 GHz 2.4 GHz 2.4 GHz







Data Link Protocol Ethernet , IEEE 802.11b , IEEE 802.11g , Fast Ethernet , IEEE 802.11n (draft) Ethernet , IEEE 802.11b , IEEE 802.11g , Fast Ethernet , IEEE 802.11n (draft) Ethernet , IEEE 802.11b , IEEE 802.11g , Fast Ethernet , IEEE 802.11n (draft) Ethernet , IEEE 802.11b , IEEE 802.11g , Fast Ethernet , IEEE 802.11n (draft) Ethernet , IEEE 802.11b , IEEE 802.11g , Fast Ethernet , IEEE 802.11n (draft) Ethernet , IEEE 802.11b , IEEE 802.11g , Fast Ethernet , IEEE 802.11n (draft)







Network / Transport Protocol PPTP , PPPoE , TCP/IP , UDP/IP L2TP , PPTP , IPSec , PPPoE Info unavailable L2TP , PPTP , IPSec , PPPoE Info unavailable L2TP , PPTP , IPSec , PPPoE , ICMP/IP







Remote Management Protocol HTTP HTTP HTTP HTTP , HTTPS Info unavailable HTTP







Features NAT support , DHCP support , MIMO technology , VPN passthrough , Dynamic DNS server , Firewall protection , Firmware upgradable , MAC address filtering , Access Point operational mode , Stateful Packet Inspection (SPI) NAT support , DHCP support , URL filtering , Syslog support , VPN passthrough , Auto-negotiation , Content filtering , Dynamic DNS server , Firewall protection , Auto-sensing per device , Quality of Service (QoS) , Auto-uplink (auto MDI/MDI-X) , Dynamic IP address assignment , Stateful Packet Inspection (SPI) NAT support , Firewall protection , Auto-uplink (auto MDI/MDI-X) , Stateful Packet Inspection (SPI) DMZ port , NAT support , DHCP support , MIMO technology , VPN passthrough , MDI/MDI-X switch , 256-bit encryption , Firewall protection , Firmware upgradable , MAC address filtering , Full duplex capability , Access Point operational mode , Stateful Packet Inspection (SPI) NAT support , URL filtering , MIMO technology , Firewall protection , DoS attack prevention , Intrusion Detection System (IDS) , Stateful Packet Inspection (SPI) DMZ port , NAT support , NAPT support , URL filtering , VPN passthrough , Dynamic DNS server , Firewall protection , Firmware upgradable , DoS attack prevention , MAC address filtering , Stateful Packet Inspection (SPI)







Compliant Standards IEEE 802.11b , IEEE 802.11g , IEEE 802.11n (draft) IEEE 802.3 , IEEE 802.1x , IEEE 802.3u , IEEE 802.11b , IEEE 802.11g , IEEE 802.11n (draft) IEEE 802.3u , IEEE 802.11b , IEEE 802.11g IEEE 802.3 , IEEE 802.3u , IEEE 802.11b , IEEE 802.11g , IEEE 802.11n (draft) IEEE 802.11b , IEEE 802.11g , IEEE 802.11n (draft) Info unavailable







System Requirements Linux , Apple MacOS 8.x , Apple MacOS 9.x , Apple MacOS X 10.x , Microsoft Windows 98/ME/NT/2000/XP Info unavailable Microsoft Windows XP , Microsoft Windows 2000 , Microsoft Windows 98 Second Edition , Microsoft Windows Millennium Edition Microsoft Windows 2000 / XP UNIX , Linux , Apple MacOS , Novell NetWare , Microsoft Windows 98/ME/2000/XP Linux , Apple MacOS , Microsoft Windows 95 , Microsoft Windows 98 , Microsoft Windows NT , Microsoft Windows XP , Microsoft Windows 2000 , Microsoft Windows Server 2003







Manufacturer Warranty Limited lifetime warranty Info unavailable Info unavailable 3 years warranty 1 year warranty 3 years warranty







Form factor External External External External External External







Dimensions (WxDxH) Info unavailable 7.6 in x 4.6 in x 1.2 in 1.4 in x 6.7 in x 7.2 in 7.4 in x 1.6 in x 6.9 in 6.8 in x 1.5 in x 8.8 in 4.8 in x 7.1 in x 1.2 in







Weight Info unavailable 10.6 oz 14.1 oz 1.1 lbs 1.3 lbs 0.9 lbs







CNET Labs long-range tests (in Mbps) Info unavailable 41.04 Info unavailable 17 32 54.1







CNET Labs maximum throughput tests (at 10 feet, in Mbps) Info unavailable 68.1 Info unavailable 71.5 72.7 83.3







CNET Labs maximum throughput tests with mixed 802.11b/g and draft N, MIMO clients (at 10 feet, in Mbps) Info unavailable 25.2 Info unavailable 46 46 58.82







Voltage Required Info unavailable Info unavailable AC 120/230 V Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable







Routing Protocol Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable Static IP routing Info unavailable Info unavailable







Localization Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable North America Info unavailable







Included Accessories Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable Info unavailable Vertical stand Info unavailable







Product name Belkin N1 Wireless Router   D-Link RangeBooster N 650 Wireless Router   Buffalo AirStation Nfiniti router and AP   Linksys WRT300N Router   Netgear WNR834B RangeMax Next Router   Trendnet Wireless N-Draft Router  







Full specifications Full Specifications Full Specifications Full Specifications Full Specifications Full Specifications Full Specifications







Price range Check latest prices
$82-130
from 18 stores
Check latest prices
$n/a
from 0 store
Check latest prices
$n/a
from 0 store
Check latest prices
$56-105
from 3 stores
Check latest prices
$53-120
from 17 stores
Check latest prices
$65-85
from 11 stores










Popular on CBS sites: Fantasy Football | Miley Cyrus | MLB | Wii | GPS | Recipes | Mock Draft


© 2008 CNET Networks, Inc., a CBS Company. All rights reserved. | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use